Douglas vs Polysleep Mattress Comparison (2024)

Alex Forest

Sleep Content Specialist

  • Up-to-Date

    i

    The information included in each mattress review at the time of publication is accurate to the best of our knowledge.

    Our reviews do not speak for future versions of these mattresses.

  • Methodology

    i

    We test and review the industry’s most popular mattresses using a weighted scoring system factoring in 30+ criteria.
    Learn more >

Which Is Better: Polysleep or Douglas?

Douglas Original is a combination foam mattress with cooling gel foam, a machine-washable cover, a 365-night sleep trial, and a 20-year warranty. Polysleep Origin 2.0 is a memory foam mattress with limited cooling features, a 100-night sleep trial, and a 10-year warranty. There’s no comparison between the two—Douglas is the clear winner.

Only Douglas Original features impressive edge support, superior motion isolation, and pressure-point relief for all sleeping positions—all for a lower price than Polysleep at just $799 for a queen size. Your Douglas mattress also comes with a free bedding bundle that includes a mattress protector, pillow(s), sheets, and pillow protector(s).

Top Pick 2024
Douglas Original Mattress

Winner:

Douglas

The Douglas Original mattress outscored Polysleep Origin 2.0 in head-to-head mattress testing conducted by third-party engineers (commissioned by us).

CANADA DAY SALE!
FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, PLUS get 50% Off All Pillows with mattress purchase!
Sale ends June 26th. See website for details >


Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas

 


Mattress Breakdown

Douglas Original features impressive edge support, superior motion isolation, and a 365-night sleep trial. Polysleep Origin 2.0 has average edge support and above-average motion isolation. These scores don’t measure up to Douglas. Polysleep also has a much shorter sleep trial—just 100 nights—with restrictions that make this timeframe even shorter.

It’s hard to find reliable Polysleep reviews online. Polysleep claims to have 6,000+ five-star reviews, but the website only shows a few hundred. One customer noted it took some effort to leave a one-star rating. Another Polysleep review on r/mattress reported trouble arranging pickup and getting a refund. Polysleep doesn’t have any reviews on its unclaimed Trustpilot profile or with the Better Business Bureau, which is unusual for an online mattress company.

In comparison, Douglas has an excellent reputation for product quality and customer care. The company is rated “Excellent” on Trustpilot and “A+” on BBB. Douglas has also earned over 13,000 five-star reviews from verified customers. Shipping and returns are cost-free and hassle-free.

When you compare Douglas vs Polysleep, it’s clear that only Douglas provides excellent value and customer service.

Douglas Original

9.9
CANADA DAY SALE!
FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, PLUS get 50% Off All Pillows with mattress purchase!
Sale ends June 26th. See website for details >

Polysleep Origin 2.0

6.1

Price (Queen)

$799

$995

Sleep Trial Nights

365

100

Warranty Years

20

10

Feel

Medium-firm

Medium-firm

Standout Features

  • 365-night risk-free sleep trial
  • 20-year warranty
  • Machine-washable cover
  • Ideal for side, back, and stomach sleepers
  • Free shipping, returns, and pickups in major metro areas
  • Cooling features like a cooling gel foam layer and moisture-wicking mattress cover
  • Free bedding bundle with your purchase
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Machine-washable cover
  • Suitable for side, back, and stomach sleepers
  • Free shipping ($85 return fee deducted from refund)

Made In

Canada

Canada

 

Get the mattress with the best sleep trial and warranty.

Shop Douglas


Mattress Sizes & Prices

Sizes*Douglas PricePolysleep Price

Twin
75″ x 38″

$599

$845

Twin XL
80″ x 38″

$649

$895

Full/Double
75″ x 54″

$699

$920

Queen
80″ x 60″

$799

$995

King
80″ x 76″

$899

$1,295

California King
84″ x 72″

$899

$1,295

RV (Bunk)
75″ x 28″

$599

N/A

RV (3/4)
75″ x 48″

$719

N/A

RV (Short Queen)
75″ x 60″

$799

N/A

* Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary.

 

Get a queen-size foam mattress for under $1,000 when you choose Douglas.

Shop Douglas


Mattress Performance Results

Douglas Original Mattress

Douglas Original

Polysleep Origin 2.0

Polysleep Origin 2.0

Firmness

Firmness

Medium-firm

Medium-firm

Edge Support

Edge Support

7.8 / 10

5.9 / 10

Motion Isolation

Motion Isolation

8.3 / 10

6.5 / 10

Bounce

Bounce

3.1 / 10

4.6 / 10

 

Firmness

Both Polysleep Origin 2.0 and Douglas Original are medium-firm mattresses. This level of firmness is ideal for all sleep styles.

However, Polysleep only has a 1″ top layer and a 2″ transition layer, both of which are memory foam.  This means your body will sink deeper into the Polysleep mattress. You may notice overheating because Polysleep doesn’t have any cooling features to balance out the heat-trapping properties of memory foam.

In contrast, Douglas Original has a 2″ top layer of cooling gel foam and a 2″ layer of Elastex® foam, which mimics the springy yet supportive feel of latex. Douglas gently contours around your body with minimal sinking so you can easily change positions while you sleep.

 

Edge Support

Foam mattresses aren’t typically known for having high edge support. But Douglas Original breaks the stereotype with an impressive edge support rating of 7.8/10. You’ll be able to sit comfortably on the edge of the bed, and you should have no difficulty getting up in the morning.

In comparison, Polysleep Origin 2.0 scored just 5.9/10. This is an average score, and considerably lower than Douglas. If you have mobility issues, sleep with a partner, or like to sit on the edge of the bed, Douglas is a better choice.

 

Motion Isolation

Motion isolation helps you enjoy a good night’s sleep without being disturbed by a restless partner, kids, or pets. Douglas Original has an exceptionally high motion isolation score of 8.3/10. You can expect to sleep soundly and not notice any movement from the other side of the mattress.

Polysleep Origin 2.0 has a lower motion isolation score of 6.5/10. This is still above average. You may not notice much movement from the other side of the bed. Still, if you’re looking for exceptional motion isolation for the most undisturbed sleep, you should look at Douglas instead.

 

Bounce

Bounce is a matter of personal preference. Low bounce is a good thing if you’re a light sleeper who’s easily woken, while higher bounce is ideal if you often change sleep positions.

Both Polysleep and Douglas scored below average for bounce. This is typical for all-foam mattresses. Polysleep Origin 2.0 earned a bounce score of 4.6/10. Douglas scored lower at 3.1/10. However, even with Douglas’s lower score, you’ll likely find it easier to change sleep positions and get out of bed. This is thanks to the Elastex® transition layer, which provides extra spring and support.

 

Choose the mattress with superior edge support and motion isolation.

Shop Douglas


Mattress Construction

Douglas mattress layers

Douglas Original

Polysleep Origin 2.0 mattress layers

Polysleep Origin 2.0

Height

Height

10″

10″

Layer 1

Layer 1

2″ ecoLight® cooling gel foam

1″ viscoelastic foam

Layer 2

Layer 2

2″ premium Elastex® foam

2″ viscoelastic foam

Layer 3

Layer 3

6″ motion-isolation support foam

7″ support foam

 

Both Douglas Original and Polysleep Origin 2.0 are combination foam mattresses with 3 layers. But only Douglas has layers of cooling gel foam and Elastex® foam for additional spring and support.

Memory foam is known for sleeping hot, and Polysleep doesn’t address the issue with any cooling features. The company claims Polysleep Origin’s open-cell layer will promote airflow, but this isn’t nearly enough to be effective. In comparison, Douglas Original comes with a moisture-wicking mattress cover and a layer of cooling gel foam to help keep temperatures comfortable.

 

Douglas Mattress Layers

  • Layer 1: The 2″ top layer of the Douglas mattress is made of ecoLight® cooling gel foam. It’s just as durable, comfortable, and body-contouring as memory foam, minus the late-night heat. It’s also more eco-conscious.
  • Layer 2: The 2″ middle layer is made of Elastex® foam for extra spring and support. This foam is latex-free, making it a good option if you’re sensitive to latex.
  • Layer 3: The 6″ bottom layer is made of motion isolation support foam. This means you’ll hardly feel a thing from the other side of the bed, even if your partner is tossing and turning all night long.

Polysleep Mattress Layers

  • Layer 1: The top (comfort) layer is 1″ of viscoelastic foam, which Polysleep claims is antimicrobial. This is fairly thin for a top layer, meaning you’ll feel more of the transition layer beneath. Foam density is 3 lb/ft³.
  • Layer 2: This 2″ transition layer is designed for body contouring and responsiveness. It has the lowest density of all layers at 1.3 lb/ft³.
  • Layer 3: The 7″ support layer has half the density of the top layer at 1.5 lb/ft³, despite needing density to support the upper layers. This may be one reason why Origin 2.0’s edge support score is lower than the original version.

Douglas’s cover design is a nod to the brand’s Canadian roots with its red-and-white colour profile and mountainscape stitching. Made with moisture-wicking, plant-based Infinitex™ fibres, the stretch knit fabric is soft, breathable, and durable to help you sleep cool all night long. The CoolSense® top cover is removable and machine-washable.

Polysleep’s top cover is white, with stitching details for added texture. The water-resistant fabric is a blend of viscose (rayon) and polyester. While Polysleep says this fabric is breathable, polyester in fact has a reputation for heat trapping. The mattress cover unzips easily and is machine washable.


Keep temperatures comfortable with Douglas’s cooling features.

Shop Douglas


Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns

Photo of the Douglas Original Mattress box on the floor in a bedroom taken from a front angle.

Douglas Original

Photo of the Nectar Original Mattress box on the floor in a bedroom taken from a front angle.

Polysleep Origin 2.0

Courier

Courier

FedEx

UPS and FedEx

Shipping Cost

Shipping Cost

Free

Free

Shipping Time

Shipping Time

3–10 business days

2–7 business days

Sleep Trial Nights

Sleep Trial Nights

365

100

Warranty Years

Warranty Years

20

10

Return Ease

Return Ease

Free pickup and return, full refund

Company picks up; charges $85 return fee

Douglas and Polysleep both ship by ground. Douglas uses FedEx, while Polysleep ships via UPS and FedEx. Douglas ships from Ontario or Alberta in 3–10 business days, while Polysleep ships from Quebec in 2–7 business days. Your mattress is delivered directly to your door throughout most parts of Canada. Additional fees may apply for some remote locations.

Douglas gives you much more time to try your mattress with a 365-night sleep trial. If you choose to return your mattress for a full refund, Douglas will pick up returns for free within the sleep trial period. Just contact customer service to coordinate your return. Both Douglas and Polysleep will donate your returned mattress to a local charity. If the mattress can’t be donated, it’ll be recycled.

Unlike Douglas, Polysleep has a much shorter trial—just 100 nights. You can only return your Polysleep mattress after the first 45 days of your trial, giving you just 55 days to complete the return. A return fee of $85 + GST will be deducted from your refund.

Polysleep provides a 10-year mattress warranty. The Douglas warranty is twice as long at 20 years.

 

Pick the mattress with the better sleep trial and warranty.

Shop Douglas


Should You Buy Douglas or Polysleep?

Douglas Original Mattress

Buy Douglas if you want…

Polysleep Origin 2.0

Consider Polysleep if you want…

  • A 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty
  • A queen-size foam mattress for under $800
  • A removable, machine-washable mattress cover
  • A mattress that’s ideal for side, back, and stomach sleepers
  • Free shipping, returns, and pickups in major metro areas
  • Cooling features like a cooling gel foam layer and a moisture-wicking mattress cover
  • Free bedding bundle with your purchase
  • To buy from a company with an “A+” BBB rating, an “Excellent” Trustpilot rating, and more than 13,000 verified five-star reviews
  • A 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty
  • A queen-size foam mattress for under $1,000
  • A removable, machine-washable mattress cover
  • A mattress that’s suitable for lighter side and back sleepers
  • Free shipping ($85 return fee deducted from refund)

 

Get the winning mattress now.

Shop Douglas