Beautyrest Mattress Review (2024)
Updated: October 9, 2024
Grace Struth
Sleep Content Lead
Our Rankings
Edge support and
motion isolation are factored into our overall mattress ratings. These scores are shown in green (scores of 5.0+), yellow (3.0–4.9), or red (2.9 and below).
Firmness,
bounce, and cooling features are a matter of personal preference and aren’t part of our rating system, so these scores are shown in grey.
1.3 /10
6.8 /10
4.8 /10
3.8 /10
Product Details
Beautyrest Black is 18″ tall and is composed of 4 layers, not counting the Euro-style pillowtop. The Simmons Beautyrest Black mattress includes cooling features like a gel foam layer, phase change material, and cooling fabrics.
This mattress has excellent motion isolation and a fair amount of bounce, according to third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us). However, it also has the weakest edge support of any mattress we’ve tested so far.
The mattress has a price range of $3,629–$4,209 and is available from twin XL to king size. It comes with several features that may explain its much higher price point. That said, several of these features are also available in lower-priced competitors like Logan & Cove Frontier.
Beautyrest Black Signature Excellence has just a handful of customer reviews on the Beautyrest and Brick websites. This makes it difficult to confirm whether the mattress would provide a good night’s sleep.
Ideal For: Side Sleepers, Back Sleepers
Looking for a luxury mattress without the luxury price tag? Meet Logan & Cove Frontier.
Read Logan & Cove Frontier Review
You May Prefer:
Logan & Cove Frontier
9.8 /10
Made in
Winner!
2024 Best Hybrid Mattress
Beautyrest Black Sizes & Prices
Want a spend less than $3,000 for a queen size hybrid mattress? Consider Logan & Cove Frontier instead.
Compare Logan & Cove vs Beautyrest
Delivery, Sleep Trial & Returns
The Brick doesn’t include delivery in Beautyrest Black’s purchase price. Shipping costs are calculated based on the distance between your home and the specific store you’re ordering from. The Brick’s website also doesn’t offer an estimate on how long it will take to deliver your mattress once purchased.
You’ll have a 90-night sleep trial to test out Beautyrest Black. That’s slightly shorter than the industry standard of 100 nights. If you’re unsatisfied with your mattress and want to return or exchange it, The Brick will charge you to ship the mattress back to the store. The Brick also doesn’t offer refunds—you can only get store credit to put toward a different mattress.
The mattress comes with a 10-year warranty covering manufacturing defects. However, Simmons has received numerous BBB complaints about product quality and warranty claims. This suggests many customers have not only needed to use their mattress warranty, but also had difficulty getting their claims honoured.
In comparison, competing hybrid mattresses like Logan & Cove Frontier come with a longer 15-year warranty, a generous 365-night sleep trial, and a full refund if you aren’t satisfied with your purchase.
Take a full 365 nights to get to know Logan & Cove Frontier.
Read Logan & Cove vs Beautyrest Comparison
Beautyrest Mattress Construction
Beautyrest Black is a hybrid mattress with 4 distinct layers. It stands 18″ high, and a queen size weighs 183 lb. Beautyrest Black’s height and weight are unusually high, even for a hybrid mattress, which will make it difficult to move.
- Layer 1: The top layer consists of HI-LUX gel memory foam. This foam’s design is meant to reduce pressure on your hips and shoulders.
- Layer 2: This memory foam layer is infused with diamonds, which is advertised to enhance Beautyrest Black’s cooling properties by redirecting heat away from the body.
- Layer 3: The transition layer of gel-based BlackLux foam is designed to be breathable and provide pressure-point relief.
- Layer 4: The support layer is made up of triple-woven, triple-wrapped T3-LUX steel coils. These coils are individually pocketed to enhance motion isolation and provide contouring support.
The Brick doesn’t publicly share layer thicknesses and foam densities for Beautyrest Black.
The mattress cover is made of Tencel, a highly breathable material that helps wick away moisture so you don’t wake up sweating. However, the “sink” provided by the pillowtop may still trap heat and counteract the mattress cover’s cooling benefits.
For an affordable luxury hybrid mattress that keeps you cool and dry, check out Logan & Cove Frontier.
Compare Logan & Cove vs Beautyrest
MattressReviews.ca commissions licensed third-party engineers and uses public data to rate mattresses on over 40 criteria.
This allows us to accurately rate and compare the performance of the mattresses reviewed on this website. Engineer independence and operating standards help ensure their results remain unbiased, valid, and reliable. Each mattress was evaluated using the same strict mattress testing methodology to protect the overall integrity of the results. The full report has been given the official stamp of approval from an APEGA-certified engineer operating under a strict ethical code of conduct.
Mattress testing conducted outside of this professional standard poses a greater risk of validity errors or reviewer bias.
1.3 /10
Edge Support
In third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us), Beautyrest Black tested exceptionally low on edge support with just 1.3/10. This is our lowest edge support score tested to date. You will likely struggle to sit on the edge and have trouble getting up in the morning.
In comparison, competitor Logan & Cove Frontier earned an edge support rating of 7.3/10. If you have mobility issues or like to sit on the edge of your mattress, Logan & Cove could be a better fit for your needs.
6.8 /10
Motion Isolation
Beautyrest Black scored above average for motion isolation with a 6.8/10. You and your partner should be able to sleep soundly without being woken by each other’s movements.
4.8 /10
Bounce
Beautyrest Black earned a bounce score of 4.8/10. This is normal for a hybrid mattress, and means you won’t sink too deeply into your bed while you’re lying on it. You should also find it easy to change sleep positions.
3.8 /10
Cooling Features
Beautyrest Black is promoted as having some cooling features. However, this mattress’s high level of “sink” may lead to heat-trapping, and counteract the mattress’s cooling benefits. Beautyrest Black earns points for its:
- Tencel cover for moisture-wicking and a cool-to-the-touch feel
- Gel-infused foam that allows for enhanced cooling
- Diamond-infused foam which transfers heat away from the body
- Open-cell foam for increased breathability
- Layer of pocketed coils that improve airflow
For a mattress with similar cooling features at just a fraction of the cost, consider Logan & Cove Frontier. With a layer of cooling gel foam, micro coils, individually wrapped steel pocketed coils, and a top-cover designed with cooling nanofibres, this luxury hybrid mattress is designed to give you a cool, comfortable sleep. Logan & Cove Frontier is available at just $1,299 for a queen size, compared to $3,649 for Beautyrest Black.
Compare Logan & Cove vs Beautyrest
Company Background
The Beautyrest brand is owned by the Simmons Bedding Company, which is based in Atlanta, Georgia. Founded in 1870, Simmons developed and sold its first Beautyrest mattress in 1925, using a design featuring individually wrapped wire coils. Simmons is a subsidiary of Serta Simmons Bedding, along with sister company Serta International. Serta Simmons Bedding filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2023.
Simmons claims to be committed to quality bedding, but customer reviews tell a different story. The company is rated “F” (unaccredited) with the BBB and has a customer review score of 1.58/5 at the time of writing.
BBB has issued an alert noting a “pattern of complaint” among customers, citing multiple reports of defective or misrepresented products, as well as poor customer service. Many customers report that when they request a replacement mattress, they receive a lower-quality mattress in exchange. Other customers report that all communication with customer service stops altogether, with no resolution.
The Beautyrest brand specifically has a “Poor” rating on Trustpilot. Multiple customer reviews report failing product quality and problems getting the company to honour warranty claims.
Shop Logan & Cove Frontier and choose a company that’s rated “A+” with BBB.
Compare Logan & Cove vs Beautyrest
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Beautyrest Black a good mattress?
Beautyrest Black has some good features, but this may not make up for its poor edge support and high price tag. We recommend Logan & Cove Frontier instead. It offers advanced cooling features and better edge support, as well as a longer sleep trial and warranty—all for a considerably lower price of $1,299 for a queen size.
Is the Beautyrest Black mattress cover machine washable?
No. Beautyrest Black has a pillowtop, so the mattress cover is not removable or machine washable.
Where is the Beautyrest Black mattress made?
The manufacturer, Simmons, produces its mattresses in the United States and Canada.
How much does a Beautyrest Black mattress cost?
Beautyrest Black costs between $3,629–$4,209, depending on the size you choose. This mattress is available from twin XL to king sizes. You might be able to purchase a Beautyrest Black mattress on sale, but even their reduced sale prices can be more expensive than similar mattresses found online.
How do I return a Beautyrest Black mattress?
You can choose between returning the mattress to The Brick yourself, or using the store’s pickup service for a fee. You will only be able to return Beautyrest Black for store credit, not a full refund.
What Beautyrest Black mattress alternatives should I consider?
We think you’ll find better value in Logan & Cove Frontier. It has advanced cooling features, better edge support, and an innovative 5-zone system for full-body support and motion isolation. With a 365-night sleep trial and 15-year warranty, Logan & Cove Frontier offers a luxury hybrid sleeping experience at just $1,299 for a queen size.
You May Prefer:
Logan & Cove Frontier
9.8 /10
Made in
Winner!
2024 Best Hybrid Mattress